The Impact of Fast Chromatography and Its Effects on Mass Spectrometry

November 1, 2008
Darwin Asa
Special Issues

Volume 0, Issue 0

The author discusses the impact of fast chromatography methods on the performance of high-resolution mass spectrometry.

Recently, many analytical chemistry groups have begun to investigate and put into practice a number of fast chromatography methods. These methods are being implemented both to increase the resolution of the separation technique and to accelerate and improve the throughput of chromatographic analyses. The problem becomes that as fast high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) methods are implemented, many traditional mass spectrometers, often used for analysis of unknowns and molecular formula determinations, lose significant resolution. This causes a significant downgrading of the analytical capabilities of the mass spectrometer (impairing its ability to perform accurate mass determination) and precludes effective deployment of many of the current generation of instruments in fast chromatography methods. The net result of the loss of performance of high-resolution mass spectrometry (MS) with increased chromatography speeds will result in an inability to identify some compounds accurately and definitively, making it more difficult to effectively perform many analyses currently done in HPLC conditions with fast chromatography. This conundrum has the potential to impact the utility of both MS and fast chromatography.

For many years, and after several notable failures, many researchers were convinced that it was impossible to design a quadrupole time-of-flight (qTOF) mass spectrometer that was able to retain its ability to perform the high-resolution measurements necessary for definitive molecular formula determination of unknowns. Conventional wisdom indicated that there were many reasons (for example, temperature stability, ion diffusion, and ion loss on grids of reflectrons) that would make it impossible to improve resolution of these types of instruments. Figure 1 shows a schematic of an instrument designed for high-resolution measurements with fast chromatography (Maxis UHR-TOF mass spectrometer, Bruker Daltonics, Billerica, Massachusetts). The instrument includes an ion chiller, a series of ion refocusing operations, a single reflectron, and temperature control of the overall flight tube of the instrument.

Figure 1: Schematic of a high-resolution TOF mass spectrometer (Maxis UHR-TOF mass spectrometer, Bruker Daltonics).

Evaluating Method Performance with Fast Chromatography of Small Molecules

To evaluate the performance of the fast chromatography–MS method for use in molecular formula determinations, a series of five unrelated drug compounds was studied. These compounds were chromatographed using a reversed-phase column over a 30-s elution gradient. The results of the initial studies are presented in Figure 2.

Figure 2: Separation and measurement of drug compounds with fast chromatography.

As can be seen, the method was able to achieve baseline separation of the five compounds in 30 s. In addition, the peak widths, when measured at half height, were all less than 1 s.

Figure 3 is a closer examination of the fourth peak in the compound series, oxybutynin. The left half of the figure shows the extracted ion chromatogram, demonstrating that even with a 1-s peak, over 20 data points were taken. This leads to the high levels of both mass accuracy (0.8 ppm) and resolution (>40,000) shown in the right half of the figure. Other peaks showed similar results.

Figure 3: Close examination of a single fast chromatography peak.

Evaluating Method Performance with Fast Chromatography of Peptides and Proteins

As many research groups are focusing more and more on protein and peptide analysis, the method was also tested for its ability to analyze proteins and peptides effectively. Figure 4 illustrates the data obtained when measuring isobaric peptides. The data shown here indicate that even with isobaric peptides, the method is able to differentiate these peptides very clearly, even when the molecular weight difference is only 50 mDa. Finally, a profile of a whole cell lysate was obtained to determine the number of proteins that could be identified. The results of this experiment are shown in Figure 5.

Figure 4: Resolution of isobaric peptides.

The high-resolution MS method enabled identification, with a high degree of certainty, of a very large number of proteins, even in a complex sample such as a cell lysate. Not only were the number of proteins identified very large, but the overall accuracy of identification was also very good. The high-resolution capability demonstrated here would be extremely useful for rapid profiling of a series of proteins or peptides in a biomarker study, for instance.

Figure 5: MS analysis of E. coli whole cell lysate.

Conclusion

Today's analytical chemistry environment demands the deployment of more sophisticated methods and instrumentation to keep pace with the profound changes in separation techniques being adopted by many laboratories. Two of the most important tools for the future will be fast chromatography and MS. The method described in this article represents a successful combination of high-resolution MS with fast chromatography.

Darwin Asa is marketing manager with Bruker Daltonics, Billerica, Massachusetts.