Special Issues
Proton OnSite
John Speranza, Proton OnSite
The most common carrier gas used for gas chromatography (GC) in the US is helium. But due to dwindling supplies, costs are rising. In this note we discuss why chromatographers may choose to switch to hydrogen, a gas easily and inexpensively produced safely through an on-site generator via electrolysis.
Helium has always been a prized resource, sealed in caverns filled with the gas to create the Helium National Reserves. But in 1996, legislation (1) allowed the sale of 0.6 billion ft3 of gas between 2005 and 2015. The law also set the price of crude helium to approximately $43/1000 scf. In 2010 the Federal Bureau of Land Management reset prices to $64.75/1000 scf, based on the Consumer Price Index (2). This increased to $75.75/1000 scf for FY 2012. Critics argue this price is still too low when assessing remaining reserves of helium (3).
In addition to the economic issues around using helium in GC, there is a question of efficiency. Both helium and hydrogen are very efficient gases to use for GC. But the differences in the properties of the gases will lead to a difference in the efficiency of the separation. Using the van Deemter equation, which predicts an optimum velocity at which there will be the minimum variance per unit column length and, hence, a maximum efficiency (4), one can deduce that linear flow rate of hydrogen can be greater than that of helium and offer equal efficiency in the gas's ability to separate peaks.
This application note is a comparison of similar-sized columns; one of helium and one of hydrogen is presented (5). Spearmint oil is separated using both a helium carrier and a hydrogen carrier (Table I).
Table I: GC column and flow details
Using hydrogen as a carrier gas in conjunction with the high efficiency column resulted in an overall speed gain of 61% compared to the original method (Figure 1).
Figure 1: The separation of spearmint oil, obtained using the conditions outlined in Table I. The first separation, (a), used a helium carrier gas and obtained results between 8 and 28 min to separate. The second separation, (b), used hydrogen carrier gas and obtained comparable resolutions between 3 and 11 min.
Hydrogen can be produced safely on-site compared to helium, which occurs rarely and is a finite resource. It should be noted that the use of stored, cooled, or pressurized hydrogen can bring with it fire and explosion (6).
Also, using the van Deemter curve, it is apparent that using hydrogen as a carrier gas instead of helium will allow an increased flow rate without effecting the efficiency of the separation, thus increasing the throughput of a laboratory.
(1) The Helium Privatization Act, P.L. 104–273 (1996).
(2) Bureau of Land Management, 2012.
(3) R. Richardson, New Scientist 2273, 19 (2010).
(4) J.J. van Deemter, F.J. Zuiderweg, and A. Klinkenberg, Chem. Eng. Sc. 5, 271–289 (1956).
(5) Agilent Technologies Inc. "Food, Flavor and Fragrance Applications" Agilent J&W GC Column Selection Guide, 250, www.agilent.com/chem/myGCcolumns, (2012).
(6) International Organization of Standardization, Basic Considerations for the Safety of Hydrogen Systems, ISO/TR 15916, 2004(E).
Proton OnSite
10 Technology Drive, Wallingford, CT 06492
tel. (203) 678-2000
Website: www.protononsite.com
Poster Presentation - RISE imaging of various phases of SiC in sintered silicon-carbide ceramics
November 12th 2024In this poster presentation applications manager Ute Schmidt discusses the use of correlative Raman-SEM (RISE Microscopy) imaging for analyzing silicon-carbide (SiC) ceramics. The main focus of the work is investigating the distribution of sub-micron structured polytypes of SiC grains on and below the surface.
FT-IR gas analysis of coal-to-ethylene glycol process
October 31st 2024Coal-to-ethylene glycol is the process by which ethylene glycol is synthesized from coal instead of traditional methods using petroleum as the raw material. This study demonstrates that Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-IR) can be a reliable alternative to simultaneously measure methyl nitrite and other process gases (such as CO and NO) using a single ABB analyzer.
Sensi+, fast, accurate and reliable monitoring of H₂S, H₂O and CO₂ in natural gas
October 31st 2024Sensi+ is a compact natural gas contaminants analyzer based on a unique tunable diode laser (TDL) technology called Off-Axis Integrated Cavity Output Spectroscopy (OA-ICOS™). The technology accurately, reliably, and simultaneously measures corrosive substances such as hydrogen sulfide, carbon dioxide and water in real-time within complex and time-varying natural gas streams. Mitigating the risks and effects of contaminants in natural gas can be challenging for pipeline operators, process industries, and natural gas utilities. These companies must manage various technologies and devices to achieve a comprehensive analysis, which can be complex, prone to failure, and costly. ABB's revolutionary Sensi+™ analyzer answers these issues.